Strange goings on in the House of Commons this week when Home Secretary Jacqui Smith MP appeared to perform one of the fastest u-turns in the history of Parliament over the Government’s proposals to tackle knife crime following a rash of fatal stabbings in recent days.
The following is an extract from the BBC News web site –
Meanwhile the home secretary denied she wanted to make youngsters caught with knives visit stab victims in hospital.
Conservative leader David Cameron told BBC Radio 5 Live: “I’m completely baffled. Over the weekend we were told by the government that knife criminals were going to be taken to accident and emergency departments.
“It sounded like a gimmick… Now they [ministers] are in wholesale retreat.”
Ms Smith insisted she had been talking at the weekend about “knife referral schemes” - where young people caught with knives would “face up to the consequences of their actions”, including “graphic” weapons awareness workshops and visits to hospitals to talk to health workers to hear about the impact of knife wounds.
“We are not, and I have never said we are, proposing to bring young people into wards to see patients,” she added.
So were the proposals reported widely by the media over the weekend half baked plans that were hastily scrapped by the Home Secretary in the face of criticism of them prior to her Commons speech? Or did the PM step in and order a change in approach? Or even worse did our national press hype up (or even worse sex up?) the briefings they were given or merely misunderstand what was said?
Meanwhile Sky News web site is also reporting it as a u-turn –
In an interview with Sky’s Adam Boulton on Sunday Live, Home Secretary Jacqui Smith said youngsters caught with knives would be forced to confront the possible consequences by bringing them face-to-face with blade victims in hospitals.
But now, the Home Office said they would instead only be expected to meet doctors to be educated about the injuries caused by knives.
“One of those proposals is that people caught carrying knives should be taken to see people in hospital who have been stabbed, or to meet the families of victims, is that correct?” Adam asked.
“It is,” replied Ms Smith.
Lib Dem home affairs spokesman Chris Huhne said Mrs Smith had been “panicked” into bringing forward proposals which evidence in the United States had shown did not work.
“Jacqui Smith is coming up with half-baked ideas because the Government has been in denial about the scale of the knife crime problem,” he added.
Mr Huhne also launched his own response to the problem in a paper entitled “A Life Away From Crime.”
The proposals include -
• The creation of a Youth Volunteer Force, to engage with young people, involve them in community projects and give them skills to benefit them in later life
• Establish Community Justice Panels across the country, where offenders admit their guilt to the community and agree on a Positive Behaviour Order as a course of action
• Create a dedicated PCSO youth officer within every Safer Neighbourhood Team to identify and work with teenagers most at risk of offending
• 10,000 more police on the streets by scrapping the ID cards scheme
• Intelligence-led stop and search and ‘hot spot policing’ targeted at gun and knife crime
• Restorative justice programs to be run in every community, specifically targeted at early intervention with widespread use in schools and care homes
Chris Huhne said: “This Government has spent 10 years trying to sound tough while failing to cut youth crime.
“In fact, ministers have embarked on the mass criminalisation of a generation of young people. By dragging more and more young people through the criminal justice system, they have reduced the fear of a criminal record and contributed to the problem.
“Instead of shock tactics to grab headlines, we need practical measures that are proven to work.
“Only the Liberal Democrats propose a dual approach to stop kids from getting involved in crime in the first place, and measures to make them face up to the consequences of their actions if they do.”
More details of the Lib Dems plans can be found here –
http://www.libdems.org.uk/media/documents/policies/A%20Life%20Away%20From%20Crime.pdf